Christ will build His church, and as the gospel spreads, so will the membership of His church.
And yet, the idea of church membership has fallen on hard times, even among Christians.
This is not surprising. Human nature prizes personal autonomy and sneers at submitting to a higher authority. In our highly-customized, hyper-personalized, self-satisfied way of life, it’s all about self and personal preferences.
We expect to see this mentality in our greater society and culture, but sometimes churches cater to this mentality as well. “Come as you are, leave as you were, whatever keeps you coming.” The idea of church membership and submitting one’s way of life to a group of Christians seems laughable.
Whatever the world may think of church membership, and even if some churches downplay or deny its necessity, I believe God makes clear through Scripture that we should practice church membership today. In no apparent order, here are twelve reasons why.
- The idea of church membership stems from a sound theology of the church.
The universal church is all Christians in heaven above and earth below. The historical church is the church on earth at a given point in history. The local church is a group of believers, organized with its own membership and officers (pastors and deacons). Scripture has letters to a single local church (e.g., 1 Cor 1:1) or a single letter to multiple local churches (e.g., Gal 1:2; Rev 1:4). Even a minimalist definition of a local church includes the ideas of a group of Christians in a certain location. More than that, these churches are spiritual families and flocks that worship God, minister to each other, and carry out the Great Commission (cf. 2 Cor 6:18; Acts 20:28).
- The church knows and even counts who its members are.
Every church practices church membership somehow, even if their formality is to practice informality. Christians gather. Someone preaches. Some sort of cohesion takes place, and things carry on.
But the New Testament commends greater precision than this. The early churches in Jerusalem and beyond clearly kept track of individuals, shown by numbers and descriptions of addition. The Jerusalem church began with 3,000 people, increased, grew to 5,000 men, and increased even more (Acts 2:41, 47; 4:4; 5:14; 6:7; 21:20). Gentile churches were clearly being planted and multiplying as well (Acts 9:31; 11:24; 13–14; 16:5; 17:4; et al). They kept track of who joined, how many, and their numbers as churches.
- The church affirms its members through baptism and the Lord’s Supper.
At Christ’s command, the local church administers baptism and practices the Lord’s Supper (Matt 28:18–20; 1 Cor 11:23–26). Baptism pictures our union with Christ in His death and resurrection, and, as we believe and are baptized into the body of Christ by the Spirit (1 Cor 12:12–13), so also Christian baptism (immersion) brings one into the membership of the local church (by the approval of the church). Just as a believer identifies with the beliefs of the baptizing church by undergoing baptism, so also the baptizing church identifies with this new believer and his shared beliefs by administering his baptism. As baptism brings one into the local church, so also the Lord’s Supper continues to express the fellowship of the church.
- The church shows itself by gathering weekly on Sundays to worship.
The churches in the New Testament gathered on Sundays to worship (cf. Acts 20:7; 1 Cor 16:2), a gathering that God commands us not to neglect (Heb 10:24–25). For a church to have any sense of coherent, consistent existence, it has to know who these people are, that they confess Christ as Savior, and that they will gather regularly for worship. A building that hosts a preacher and audience with no sense of membership is more of a chapel than a church. Worse, if a “church” follows a business model, it will put on a show to attract a crowd. The habit of Christians to gather weekly to encourage one another to love and good works—this is the habit of a group of people who are members of one another as a church.
- Voting on church matters requires knowing who church members are.
Churches vote to appoint their officers, include new members, and exclude unrepentant members (Acts 6:3; 14:23; Matt 18:17). Paul even spoke of a “majority” that once put a man out of the Corinthian church (2 Cor 2:6). Receiving a vote and determining a majority within the vote is only meaningful if a church knows first who its members are.
- The identity of subgroups within the church assumes that the church knows who all of its members are.
The New Testament identifies multiple subgroups within churches, one of them being widows. Not only did Paul commend “a list” of widows for church care (1 Tim 5:9), he even made it clear that these were known to be faithful widows within the church (1 Tim 5:3–6). As in Ephesus where Timothy received these instructions, so also it was in Jerusalem in Acts 6. The church knew its membership as a whole and thus its widows within the church (Acts 6:1–7). Other subgroups within the church include its pastors and deacons (e.g., Phil 1:1).
The above examples are positive. We could support the idea of membership from subgroups by using negative examples as well. As a church knows its membership, sinful divisions are easily apparent. A subgroup could prefer one leader to the exclusion of others (e.g., 1 Cor 1:12) or hold to an aberrant doctrine (e.g., Acts 15:1, 5). In one sense, a subgroup defined by error implies church membership all the more as this subgroup defines itself apart from what it once held in common with the membership as a whole.
- The offices of pastor and deacon assumes a body of people to lead and serve.
A pastor shepherds a flock, a specific group of people allotted to his charge (1 Pet 5:2). Pastors know every soul for whom they will give account (Heb 13:17). Likewise, these Christians recognize these men as their pastors (1 Thess 5:12–13). As for deacons, they likewise serve the church, knowing who these people are and meeting their specific needs (e.g., Acts 6:1–7). The thought of having pastors and deacons with no thought to who they lead and serve simply doesn’t make sense.
- Members of the church hold each other accountable for the Christian life.
One of the means of grace is mutual accountability to one another (Rom 15:14). Not everyone is diligent enough to avoid every significant sin. We snatch some from the fire (Jude 22), turn the wanderer back to the truth (James 5:19–20), and restore the one caught in a trespass (Gal 6:1). While it is enough that we are safe in the hands of God and His Son (John 10:28–29), sometimes God’s keeping hand is exercised through His people. But if you do not commit yourself to the membership of a church, its pastors and people may not know you as a sheep, and you hinder yourself from the help that God gives through the members of a church.
- We use our spiritual gifts to minister to the members of our church.
Spiritual gifts can be used beyond one’s local church, but they are primarily used to edify the members of one’s local church. Each individual part works together to build up the whole (Eph 4:16). A singular member cannot be a church unto himself (cf. 1 Cor 12:14). As God has gifted us spiritually, we use these spiritual gifts to serve one another for His glory (1 Pet 4:10–11). This variety of gifts and unity in Christ is one of the means whereby God helps the church to look more like His Son (Eph 4:11–16).
- Making disciples takes place in the context of the local church.
If a Christian without a church wins someone to Christ, what pastor will that new convert have? Where will he meet to worship? Who are the other Christians to edify him with their gifts? The soulwinner is not a church unto himself. Evangelism is greatly hindered, and an intentionally isolated Christian cannot strongly show his love for his fellow Christians if he refuses to join a church (John 13:34–35).
- Church membership promotes unity around the gospel and key beliefs.
The New Testament bears memorable sayings and maxims that give the idea of a standard articulation of truth even then (e.g., the “trustworthy sayings” of the Pastoral Epistles). Sound creeds and statements today can provide a point of unity for a local church to know who they are by what they believe (cf. Eph 4:4–6). I believe a statement of faith for the local church is essential in our day and age when heresies and differences abound. Church members finds clarity and precision in doctrine and practice by agreeing to some kind of statement of faith and practice.
- Church membership benefits the whole Christian.
The church does not just provide instruction but gives blessings in all of life. God’s people care for one another in every way—as children or elderly (Eph 6:1–3; Titus 2:1–3), single or married (1 Cor 7:7–8; Eph 5:22–33), orphan or widow (James 1:27), rich or poor (1 Tim 6:17–19; James 2:5). We persevere through trials together, serve one another, and will one day spend eternity together. Why would we not begin to enjoy that fellowship in the present?
Conclusion
To call one’s self a Christian while refusing to join a church—this kind of thinking is dangerous, sinful, and wrong. God forbids anyone to exist as a lone ranger Christian apart from the church. Church history calls the Christian with no church home an “irregular Christian.” Maybe he doesn’t even attend anywhere and simply “does church” somehow online. A profession here, a video of a service there—he’s got all the God he needs. Folks, this is not the way.
From all of the reasons above, Scripture commends us to be members of one another in the local church. Formal church membership may look different from one church to the next and from one culture to the next, but the basic concept exists. If you’re not one already, become a member of a spiritually healthy local church!








